National Anti-vivisection Society

 

National Antivisection Society

Animals suffering in labs rises - predicted to rise again

Posted: 9 July 2012. Updated: 17 September 2012

1

The NAVS is predicting yet another increase in animals being mutilated, infected, poisoned and given harmful genetic defects in UK laboratories when the Home Office releases the 2011 `Statistics of Scientific Procedures on Living Animals´ tomorrow, 10 July.

Despite the widespread availability of advanced alternative methods, and ignoring the focus on animal replacement in the new EU Directive on animal research, the UK remains one of Europe´s biggest animal users[1] - and the number one user of laboratory primates in the EU, some of which are born of wild-caught parents.

Numbers of animals used in UK labs has increased steadily for nearly a decade, from 2,567,713 in 2001 to 3,642,517 in 2010, an increase of over 1 million animals.

In 2010, the number of procedures on non-human primates in the UK increased by 10%, to 4,688 experiments. Last year also saw an increase in the number of procedures conducted to produce and use genetically modified (GM) and harmful mutant (HM) animals, to over 1.6 million procedures. This represented 54% of all procedures, raising many welfare concerns.

New EU rules on animal experiments are being implemented this year, with no opportunity for a public or parliamentary debate. The UK Government is being urged by the NAVS to use this as an opportunity to ensure that action is taken to ensure that non-animal methods are brought into use.

1

NAVS Chief Executive, Jan Creamer: "It is shameful that while the world progresses with advanced technology, Britain is responsible for mutilating and infecting increasing numbers of defenceless animals - and government bodies, charities and others are foolish enough to pay for it. The real cutting edge of scientific research is the advanced, non animal methods that the Government needs to bring in now. The new EU Directive has the aim to replace the use of animals in research, the public wants to see advanced research without animal suffering and the technology is there. It´s time to stop funding these researchers who can´t change with the times.”

The sheer number of animals used in procedures in the UK each year is shocking. Recent animal research in the UK has included:

  • Nottingham researchers wanted to see what effect there would be on the livers of unborn lambs if the mothers´ diets were restricted; they were hoping to establish a large animal model of non-alcoholic fatty liver disease. Twin lambs were born to each ewe and at 7 days one was killed and the other remained alive, receiving differing amounts of food. Some were overfed (30% extra food) and they were kept in a barn, which restricted ability to exercise by 65%. At one year old the lambs were stunned, bled to death and a liver sample taken. These experiments simply repeat previous experiments carried out by this same team, while other researchers have already studied the impact of diet, pregnancy and child development in humans.

  • London researchers made three adult macaque monkeys perform “grasp tasks” while electrical currents were delivered to their brains and whilst electrodes picked up the activity in their brains. This was repetition of previous experiments. The animals were restrained by a headpiece fixed onto their skulls while electrodes were inserted into the brain through a hole in the skull. At the end of the experiment two of the animals were killed. This research flies in the face of known differences between monkey and human brains, and these highly intelligent, emotional and sensitive animals, known to fish and use tools in the wild, would have been aware and terrified by the whole procedure. It is disturbing that one of the funders of this research is the Government´s National Centre for the 3Rs (a body set up to show government commitment to replacement of animals in research).

1

  • Bristol researchers infected seven cats with anaemia taken from other infected cats, in an effort to create a new test for the disease. The cats were described as `pathogen free´, which means they were born and lived in a sterile barren environment. Following this blood was taken approximately every fortnight for about 5 months. Clinical signs of the disease include weakness, rapid breathing, increased heart beat, collapse and fever. Animals were killed at the end of the experiment, but it is not clear how many. This experiment was sloppy and unnecessary - other scientists have already noted that some laboratories offer other tests for this disease.

  • At Porton Down´s Biomedical Sciences, Defence Science and Technology Laboratory in Wiltshire 10 common marmosets were used to track disease progression. The monkeys´ heads were placed in a chamber and infected by aerosol, for ten minutes. Devices were implanted under their skin to record their temperatures. Pairs of monkeys were killed every 24 hours after infection and their blood and organs harvested and analysed. The results showed lung inflammation, necrosis of their lymph nodes, hepatitis and pneumonia. The animals involved in this study would have clearly suffered during the onset of symptoms of tularaemia, particularly those animals that were left to suffer through to the later stages of disease. The results showed lung inflammation, necrosis of their lymph nodes, hepatitis and pneumonia. There was also an increase in temperature, and by 96 hours post infection, the animals´ behaviour was subdued.

For a decade, the Lord Dowding Fund has been funding the neuroimaging group at the Aston Brain Centre, headed by Professor Paul Furlong, which engages in a wide range of research activities studying human behaviour and brain function. The group works to establish how new techniques may be used to replace animal experiments. Projects include vision, neurodevelopment and clinical research, cognition and pharmacokinetics (drug characteristics).

In the latest issue of New Science, we asked Professor Furlong to outline one use of animals that could be replaced today with non-animal methods and he responded "In the field of behavioural neuroscience, primates are trained to respond to a stimulus in order to study brain cell changes associated with their response and behaviour. In many cases I believe that the questions could more effectively be studied non-invasively using neuroimaging techniques, especially with pain research, where human cognition is a vital factor in understanding the response to pain and analgesia."

Read about our campaign on the UK vivisection law

Make a donation

Read our Access Denied Report which details experiments on macaque monkeys by Roger Lemon and a team at the University of London’s Institute of Neurology (referred to above):
Introduction / Legal critique / Animal Housing / Scientific critique / Summary

Reference:
1. The UK is the second biggest animal user in Europe, behind France, and ahead of Germany and then Spain. Total animals used: France = 2,328,380, UK = 2,266,884, Germany = 2,021,782 and Spain and 897,859.


Share

© National Anti-Vivisection Society

Cookie preferences