July 2001: The Home Office has released the statistics for animals used in in UK laboratories during 2000.
Primates
Just under 57% of all experiments performed on non-human primates used animals supplied from abroad.
This is due to the “recent closure of the main non-human primate supplying establishment [Shamrock Farm], a designated UK source. There were 87 procedures on cats acquired from non-designated sources in the UK and 176 on cats from abroad (due to the closure of the main designated UK supplier [Hillgrove]); 404 procedures on dogs from non-designated UK sources and 363 on dogs from abroad, with another 336 procedures on dogs “acquired from other sources".
Non-Toxicology
The greatest use of animals for non-toxicological purposes was for pharmaceutical research and development, accounting for 20% of experiments.
Next came immunology and cancer research at 16% and 11% respectively.
Toxicity testing decreased from 1999 by about 16%, amounting to 17% of total procedures last year. 84% were to comply with legislative or other regulatory requirements.
Every 12 seconds an animal dies in an experiment in a UK laboratory.
Every 6 seconds a UK lab animal is killed simply because it is surplus to requirements.
It’s happening in a laboratory near you.
The NAVS responded to the statistics with a national press campaign, targeting experiments at institutions around the UK.
Belfast
A technique that has been used in human patients for 20 years was investigated in rabbits at Queen’s University. Veins and arteries in the rabbits’ legs were clamped to stop blood flow(1).
Other rabbits were force fed antioxidant drugs for 2 weeks before the same procedure, despite that clinical studies on humans have already shown that an antioxidant diet reduces muscle injury and therefore lung damage(1).
During the experiments an anti-clotting agent, heparin, was given to the rabbits. Previous research shows that the effect of heparin in rabbits is not consistent with that in humans(2).
1. Harkin DW, et al. Reperfusion injury is greater with delayed restoration of venous outflow in concurrent arterial and venous limb injury. British journal of Surgery 2000, 87: 734-741
2. The Lancet, 1965, Vol. 1: 729-730.
Birmingham
In a badly planned experiment at the University of Birmingham, 25 ducklings were force fed a cocktail of drugs and hormones to compare the effects of an over and under active thyroid gland on tissue growth. It was found that there is not always a relationship between thyroid activity and tissue characteristics. The researchers admitted that they anticipated species differences, and that it was possible that these results “were influenced by an independent effect"(1) such as food intake and also by the different enzymes in the ducklings’ tissues.
1. Bishop C.M. et al. (2000) Tissue-specific regulation of thyroid hormone receptor mRNA isoforms and target gene proteins in domestic ducks. Journal of Endocrinology 165:607-615
Cambridge
Monkeys received piglet kidneys during xenotransplant experiments by researchers from Imutran Ltd, Papworth Hospital and Cambridge University. The spleen was removed from some animals, and all received immunosuppressive drugs. The monkeys survived no longer than animals used previously. All died or were killed within 78 days.
Non-animal methods were being investigated at the time of this experiment. Positive progress had already been made in “efforts to engineer tissues to fill in for failing hearts, livers and kidneys"(1). In contrast, animal researchers are apparently unable to keep their victims alive. Even if xenotransplants achieved some success, there would remain the risk of animal viruses passing to the human population and causing epidemics; risks are increased by patients having to take drugs to suppress their immune system(2).
1. Science, 16 April 1999, Vol 284: 422- 425
2. Stoye JP et al. Endogenous retroviruses: a potential problem for xenotransplantation? Ann. NY Acad. Sci, 1999; 30 (4):390-396
Cardiff
University of Cardiff researchers drilled holes through the skulls of 117 rats and damaged their brains in an attempt to see how this would affect memory; it did. However, rats “are difficult subjects in which to study the mechanisms of learning and memory"(1) and previously research into human memory was “complicated by findings from behavioural studies of rats"(2).
1. New Scientist; 17 March 1990: 62
2. Science, vol 253, 1991: 1380-1386
Edinburgh
Medical Research Council workers injected newborn rats and marmoset monkeys with varying levels of hormone suppressing chemicals in order to see the effects on sperm production. Both responded differently. It was found that the cells responsible for sperm production in the marmosets were unaltered while the production of sperm by the rats was permanently affected.
It was concluded that the marmoset is a useful model for humans, despite that the growth period of these cells in marmosets is neonatal and ceases at the start of infancy, whereas the human cell growth continues after the neonatal period, into puberty.
Limited studies have been carried out in humans. The Lord Dowding Fund is currently funding research at Birmingham University into human fertility in which human testicular tissue is studied in vitro.
Sharpe RM, et al. Effect of neonatal gonadotropin-releasing hormone antagonist administration on Sertoli cell number and testicular development in the marmoset: comparison with the rat. Biology of Reproduction, 2000, 62: 1685-1693.
Glasgow
At the University of Glasgow holes were drilled in the skulls of 16 adult cats, and their brains damaged, to test a drug’s effects on human brain injury. The results showed that the brain damage was varied; this had already been reported previously.
Clinical trials of this drug type had already been “stopped prematurely"(1) due to safety “concerns"(1). It had been proved unsuitable for humans, and described as “irrelevant to brain function following damage to these tissues as a result of stroke or head injury"(1). These pointless results could not be applied to humans and mere curiosity killed the cats.
1. Yam, P.S. et al. (2000) NMDA receptor blockade fails to alter axonal injury in focal cerebral ischema. Journal of Cerebral Blood Flow and Metabolism 20:772-779
Sandwich, Kent
At Pfizer Central Research laboratories, eletriptan, a new anti-migraine drug that had already undergone human trials, was compared for efficacy and side-effects in rats and dogs with sumatriptan, an anti-migraine drug currently in human use(1).
Dogs were anaesthetised, their chests opened and the heart suspended in a cradle. Drugs were administered and the effect on the heart and blood vessels were monitored. The effect of eletriptan on blood flow had already been studied in pigs and people. The potency of both drugs in contracting human arteries in isolated preparations had also been assessed.
Holes were drilled in rats’ skulls, elctrodes inserted into the brain and a nerve electrically stimulated while drugs were administered. It was already known that the ability of similar drugs to inhibit nerve inflammation in rats does not indicate that they are effective migraine treatments.
The researchers admitted the unreliability of animal tests “...only clinical experience over a long period of time will confirm or refute...” whether eletriptan will have less effect than sumatriptan on the coronary arteries.
As far as is known, migraine only occurs in humans(2).
1. Gupta, P et al. (2000). The in vivo pharmacological profile of eletriptan (UK-116,044): a potent and novel 5-HT 1B/1D receptor agonist. European Journal of Pharmacology 398: 73-81
2. Goadsby, P & Hoskin, KL (1997) Journal of Anatomy 190: 367-375
London
At the Institute of Neurology (previously infiltrated by an NAVS Field Officer), electric shocks were given to the spinal nerves of 4 squirrel monkeys in order to compare nerve control of their arm movements with that of cats and macaque monkeys. The skull was opened and part of the spinal cord was deliberately damaged(1).
The animals were fully anaesthetised during surgery, but for the remainder, they were under a drug which induces only light anaesthesia, has poor pain-relief and is not recommended for non-human primates(2,3).
The team, led by Roger Lemon, has carried out this experiment on squirrel monkeys before, and transmission of nerve impulses from this area of the brain and spinal cord has been studied by others, in people(1).
The researchers stated: “We recognise the dangers of making these comparisons both between laboratories and between species". A recent report challenges their interpretation of results(1).
1. Nakajima, K; Maier, M A; Kirkwood, P A; Lemon, R N (2000). Striking differences in transmission of corticospinal excitation to upper limb motoneurons in two primate species. Journal of Neurophysiology; 84: 698-709
2. Flecknell, P (1996). Laboratory Animal Anaesthesia, 2nd Edition; Academic Press: 68 & 215
3. Kohn, Dennis (1997 Anaesthesia & Analgesia in Laboratory Animals; Academic Press: 240-241 & 250-253
Oxford
University of Oxford researchers investigated whether stunted foetal growth could be counterbalanced by insulin. 10 ewes, each 4 months pregnant with twins, were starved for 24 hours. A tube was inserted into the foetuses; the ewes were then housed individually in metabolism cages. One of each set of foetuses in 7 of the ewes were given growth stunting hormones and insulin, for 2 weeks. The wombs complete with foetuses were removed for analysis(1).
Stress is known to affect results, but the ewes had just 4 days to acclimatise: “It is good practice to allow plenty of time for the animal to acclimatise to its new situation, not only on welfare grounds but also because the experimental results may be influenced."(2)
The purpose of establishing whether insulin prevents stunted growth in sheep foetuses receiving insufficient nutrients and oxygen is not stated(1), implying that this was curiosity.
1. Bassett JM, Hanson C (2000). Prevention of hypoinsulinemia modifies catecholamine effects in foetal sheep. American Journal of Physiology, Regulatory Integrative Comp. Physiol., 278: R1171-R1181
2. Laboratory Animals 1997, 31: 116-124
Sheffield
In an attempt to mimic nerve damage during tooth extraction in humans, experiments were carried out on ferrets at the University of Sheffield. The tongue nerves of 40 ferrets were exposed and different injuries inflicted and allowed to heal for 3 days, 3 weeks, 3 or 6 months. Then, the time taken for each animal to drink Bovril was measured to establish whether abnormal feeling had developed.
Before being killed, the lower jaw was opened, the tongue stitched to a platform, and stimuli applied, then measured.
The vivisectors did not appear to learn anything new, as in common with their previous studies, they demonstrated abnormal nerve activity and sensitivity at the site of injury. They admitted species differences: “Great variation has been observed in these characteristics [response to stimuli] between studies undertaken in different species and on different nerves".
Yates JM, et al. Ectopic neural activity from myelinated afferent fibres in the lingual nerve of the ferret following three types of injury. Brain research, 2000, 874: 37-47
Southampton
Fibrillation is when the heart goes into rapid twitching mode. Defibrillators, which administer electric shocks, are sometimes necessary to restore normal rhythm.
To test the safety of a new type of defibrillator 8 pigs underwent surgery and multiple electric shocks. A tube was inserted into the main neck vein and through this an Angeflex defibrillator was pushed towards the heart. The heart was made to fibrillate by an electric shockwave at short intervals, alternating with a defibrillating shock. The hearts were assessed for damage(1).
The researchers appear doubtful about their results due to species differences, stating: “inevitably there are several distinct differences. The relation of the porcine heart within the thorax and mediastinum [part of the chest containing the heart] is of a different orientation to that of man and so direct comparisons may not be valid".
Similar experiments had been carried out by others using dogs. The present team conducted a similar experiment on 10 pigs, published in 1999(2).
1. Roberts, PR et al. (2000). A multifilamented electrode in the middle cardiac vein reduces energy requirements for defibrillation in the pig. Heart 84: 425-430
2. Roberts, PR et al. (Mar 1999). J. Interventional Cardiac Electrophysiology 3 (1): 55-60
Action
Find the experiment which took place closest to where you live.
Write to your local newspaper: Describe the experiment, saying where it took place and call on readers to join the NAVS to end this suffering. Include our address in your letter.
Write to your MP: Describe the experiment and tell them that it is being performed locally (or in their constituency); that you are appalled that such research is permitted and that the government is allowing animal experiments to continue to rise.
July 2001