Posted: 1 October 2014. Updated: 1 October 2014
Requirements of the EU Directive mean that reporting the actual severity of animal experiments must be carried out at the end of the animalīs life. Previously in the UK, only an estimated severity was required at the beginning of research, but now the actual severity must be categorised and included in the annual statistical returns. The Home Office has stated that this change “is intended to improve transparency and provide a focus for the refinement of the most severe procedures.”
The working document considers that assessing and assigning actual severity to animals used in experiments will be of benefit in improving scientific data quality “due to better welfare” . Despite this claim, in reality, scientific data will still be fundamentally flawed due to species differences between human and non-human animals.
In order to assess how much an animal has suffered during the course of the research, the document gives guidance on the process of severity assessment. This involves overarching categories of assessment that apply to all species, such as appearance and behaviours, which are then used to produce a study-specific list of welfare indicators. This is said to have been devised so as to avoid a system which is “unnecessarily bureaucratic and time-consuming” whilst minimising the risk of “missing signs of suffering” . Something as essential as evaluating the level of pain, suffering or distress that is being inflicted on an animal used in research, should not be constrained by considerations such as bureaucracy and time limits.
Behaviours and clinical signs are used in the “cage side assessment” . Assuming this means that the welfare of animals is assessed by simply observing animals in their housing environment, it is of concern where problems may not be picked up without a physical examination. Whilst carrying out an investigation of a genetic modification laboratory, the NAVS observed problems of over breeding and an inability to manage colonies which meant keeping control of the colonies was almost impossible. The NAVS investigator noted confusion in the breeding of mice and signs of copulation in females being missed, resulting in unplanned litters. In this case, a lack of careful observation of animals, due to the huge numbers, led to animal suffering and highlights why thorough assessment of animals is necessary to avoid causing further harm.
Find out about other EWG reports on
Education and training
Genetically altered animals
Non-technical project summaries
Project evaluation/retrospective assessment
Support our work to end animal experiments