National Anti-vivisection Society

 

National Antivisection Society

Who wants a Royal Commission on vivisection?

1

Royal Commission on Vivisection


The call for a Royal Commission on vivisection has grown since an undertaking was given in the Labour Party’s ‘New Life for Animals’ leaflet, prior to the 1997 election.

The NAVS does not favour a Royal Commission (RC). We do not believe it to be an effective way forward, for two principle reasons:-

Firstly, whilst such a body sat, the government would have the perfect excuse to shelve the issue, and it could jeopardise the campaign to have animal experiments drawn under the Freedom of Information Act.

Secondly, the criticisms made of the unfair way in which the last RC (in 1906) was stacked against the opponents of animal experiments still stand. There is no reason to believe that any new RC would be fairly constituted, whatever efforts or promises the Government might make.

We remain firmly of the belief that inclusion of animal experiments under the Freedom of Information Act is the way forward.

Freedom of Information would allow us to challenge proposals to use animals before the experiment takes place, and bring in our experts to suggest a non-animal alternative.

This would have the dual effect of, ideally, eliminating some experiments, as well as giving us the opportunity to prove that animal experiments are not the best way to conduct scientific and medical research.

It would provide a practical, ongoing, mechanism by which animal experiments can be eliminated.

It could also build a body of knowledge at the Home Office on non-animal research.

Vivisection features in a wide range of fields - from teaching of life sciences, psychology to pharmacology, to safety testing, to basic research and genetic engineering. Each area raises different issues, so different solutions must be presented.

We also do not believe that it would be helpful if the Royal Commission were to revisit the debate about the ethics of vivisection . This particular debate has raged for over 100 years, and it is unlikely that any Royal Commission would be able to resolve it.

What’s wrong with Royal Commissions?

A group of commissioners is appointed to take evidence in a series of hearings, and produce a report. The Government may ignore the report, or may act upon it.

The conclusions of the report are governed by who sits on the commission (each will already hold a view ) , the terms of reference (they can choose to restrict their evidence ), and from whom they decide to take evidence (they do not have to take evidence from everyone who wishes to submit).

Even after a Commission has reported (and the Commissioners may not agree with each other, anyway), the whole issue has to be argued all over again through the political process anyway.

Royal Commissions are notorious as a tool to shelve contentious issues. Some sit for decades. All legislation on the issue is hung up, while Government is temporarily relieved of responsibility for making a decision.

The first problem would be to ensure that the Commission was balanced. The NAVS believes there is next to no chance of a balanced Commission.

The next problem would be the remit and hearing of evidence. The Government, the pro - vivisection scientists advising Government, and the Commissioners, determine the remit and whose evidence they will take. See our comments on the 1906 Royal Commission,below.

At the end, we get an enormous volume of evidence from opposing views, buried in parliamentary reports which the public will never see and the media has no time to read. The ‘verdict’ of the RC is likely to be whatever view the wealthiest lobby group promotes.

Both Government and provivisection interest will be busy persuading the public that there has been a fair hearing of the issues, each for their own reasons.

The Last Royal Commission

It is important to understand some of the background on the two Royal Commissions on vivisection.

Little was known about vivisection when the first Royal Commission on Vivisection recommended in 1876 that animal experiments be controlled by legislation.

This resulted in the 1876 Cruelty to Animals Act, which remained in force until it was replaced by the 1986 Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act.

The last Royal Commission on Vivisection, which sat from 1906 to 1908 and reported in 1912, was a farce.

The terms of reference were “to enquire into and report upon the practice of subjecting live animals to experiments, whether by vivisection or otherwise, and also to enquire into the law relating to that practice, and its administration: and to report whether any, and if so what, changes are desirable".

The NAVS complained that it was stacked against the antivivisectionists, who were not given a fair opportunity to present their arguments. Public, press, and lawyers were barred.

The 1906 RC resulted in some regulatory and administrative changes, but the debate was no further forward afterwards . Vivisection remained secret.

The Fix

The composition of the 1906 Commission was an issue: of eleven Commissioners, five were from the medical and veterinary professions, and four were ‘lay’ members. Of the five scientific representatives, three had been, or were, licensed vivisectors, and one had already declared that they were not opposed to animal experiments. One of the four ‘lay’ members was a Home Office official. The Home Office refused to allow antivivisection scientists to sit on the Commission.

The Commissioners decided that they would not allow public cross-examination of vivisectors or Home Office officials.

We were also barred from being represented by counsel, when skilful examination and cross-examination of witnesses was vital. Our one witness,The Hon. Stephen Coleridge, was forced to curtail his evidence, and not allowed the same amount of time as the opposition. We were denied the right to ask questions of Home Office officials.

Our Evidence

Our major complaints about the law on animal experiments were:-

The secrecy with which the 1876 Cruelty to Animals Act was administered ; that the Home Office Inspectorate was biased towards vivisection; that the Home Office’s administrative procedures protected the vivisectors rather than the animals; that the Home Secretary’s advisors were pro-vivisection. Sound familiar?

Our witness also charged Home Office officials with being so biased in favour of vivisection that they did not consider it their duty to make efforts to protect animals from illegal treatment. Sound familiar? In the notorious Feldberg case, just a few years ago, the official inquiry admitted that the Home Office Inspectorate did not consider it to be their job to seek out and report upon improper laboratory practice; and so they allowed a vivisector, Feldberg, to continue to burn cats and cut open conscious rabbits.

Speaking for the NAVS at the Second Royal Commission, The Hon. Stephen Coleridge also complained that Home Office officials had acted as injudicial defenders of the vivisectors . Without being aware of the similarities at the time, 91 years later, we made the same points in the Accountability report. Request your free copy to send to your MP.

Our 1906 witness, Stephen Coleridge, also charged the Home Office with “shielding names of licensees as they know to have broken the law". Again, refer Accountability, in particular, point on lack of information on law breakers.

In 1906 we also charged Home Office officials with preparing “evasive and insufficient replies in the House of Commons". See our comments in Accountability on evasive replies, and dismissive responses to undercover investigations.

Our witness suggested to the 1906 RC that in addition to guarantee of scientific fitness, a certificate of humaneness should be required before a licence was issued - a revealing response was given by Lord Justice Fletcher Moulton, an expert witness on ethics, who dismissed this as “intolerable insolence".

The vivisectors, on the other hand , welcomed the Commission as an opportunity to lay before the nation a record of the ‘magnificent work’ done for humanity by experiments on animals. With their critics all but excluded, they could say what they wished.

The 1906 Commission concluded that valuable knowledge had been gained, which we would not have otherwise obtained, and that similar methods of investigation if pursued in the future would achieve similar results, and finally, that animal experiments were morally justified.

Thus, the 1906-1908 Royal Commissioners left the question precisely where it had been before they commenced their investigation.

© National Anti-Vivisection Society

Cookie preferences