Posted: 1 October 2014. Updated: 1 October 2014
The EWG published a document regarding the evaluation of project applications and the requirements for any retrospective reviews of research projects.
The level of detail required in project applications is allowed to vary according to considerations such as the duration of the project and the species and number of animals used. The NAVS has previously expressed our opinion that any use of animals for scientific purposes should be fully scrutinised. Any proposal that reduces the requirements for project application also reduces the transparency of the process.
The document acknowledges that basic research can be carried out to expand knowledge, which is “a suitable objective in its own right” ; however it is stated that the research “benefits should go beyond “it would be nice to know” . Exactly how evaluators would be able to distinguish this as a reason for conducting this kind of blue skies research is not stated.
The NAVS has long campaigned in the UK for access to the project licence applications before they are granted to ensure adherence to the Government´s 3Rs policy of replacement, reduction and refinement in animal experiments. Most importantly, this access would provide us with the necessary information to recommend alternatives, identify duplications or other comparable research, thus enabling us to challenge such research before it starts, i.e. before animals are used. The EU working document outlines models of the project evaluation process which involve lay members and experts in alternatives, as well as experts in animal protection and ethics.
Although some project licence applications in the UK are referred to the Animals in Science Committee, whose members come from various backgrounds, inspectors are the main evaluators of project licences and external opinion is not employed on all occasions. In fact, the Home Office guidance states that, if external assessors are used, the project applicant will not only be informed, and their views considered regarding the selection of the assessor, but they will usually be told who they are and the questions the external assessor will be asked.
In the assessment of the predicted benefits of the work compared to the harms caused to animals, the document acknowledges that “The “importance” of work is a subjective judgement changing with time and place and depending on a number of variables such as culture, environment, economic situation, acquired knowledge, emerging unsolved scientific problems and ethical values” . Changes in public perception are cited as having an impact on the acceptability of certain procedures which is another reason why openness and transparency surrounding animal in experiments is essential.
Retrospective assessment of some animal research should include feedback to researchers of issues raised, dissemination of positive and negative information about animal use and the 3Rs, an update of the non-technical summary for the project and the use of information to review the effectiveness of the project evaluation process.
Some other definitions were clarified by the expert working group, including:
Practices exempt from the requirements of the Directive
Included are non-experimental agricultural practices, such as castrating lambs, debeaking poultry; non-experimental clinical veterinary practice such as biopsies for diagnosis; veterinary clinical trials; practices undertaken for purposes of animal husbandry and those undertaken primarily for identification of an animal, such as an ear tag. Practices which are “not likely to cause pain, suffering, distress or lasting harm equivalent to, or higher than, that caused by the introduction of a needle in accordance with good veterinary practice” and therefore also exempt from the requirements of the Directive, include “minimal restraint” for imaging procedures, breeding genetically altered animals which are expected to have no clinically detectable adverse effects and food withdrawal for 24 hours or less in rats.
Multiple generic projects
These are procedures which are believed to be “generally well-established and the likely consequences on the animals are well-understood” . This can apply to tests carried out to fulfil the needs of regulatory toxicology and to projects where animals are used for the production of biological products, such as antibodies. The fact that the procedures are considered “generally well-established” does not mean that the animals will not suffer (as our exposés of laboratories such as HLS and Inveresk have shown). In addition the use of GA animals is increasing and therefore maintenance of a GA line should be more closely scrutinised, not rubber-stamped.
Find out about other EWG reports on
Education and training
Genetically altered animals
Non-technical project summaries
Severity assessment
Support our work to end animal experiments