National Anti-vivisection Society

 

National Antivisection Society

European Commission Expert Working Group on genetically altered animals

Posted: 1 October 2014. Updated: 1 October 2014

The document produced during this EWG aimed to define the meaning of the “creation” and “maintenance” of genetically altered (GA) animals in order for them to be correctly counted and their use authorised. The creation of a “new” GA animal line, with a desired trait, requires authorisation. However, breeding of GA animals to maintain a desired trait does not require authorisation, if it is assessed that the alteration does not result in harmful characteristics. Assessment is made based on two generations of GA animals. However, the alteration, or mutation may also not be immediately obvious; “Up to three generations of breeding and screening may be required to detect mutant progeny” . 1

During the creation of GA animals, procedures such as vasectomy, surgery to implant embryos, and the injection of hormones to induce “superovulation", are all counted as procedures. Any genetically normal animal to be born during the creation of GA animal lines are not counted for inclusion in the statistical reports. A created line of GA animal is considered “established” when the genetic alteration has been observed over a minimum of two generations and when a welfare assessment has been completed. However, as mentioned the alteration, or mutation, may also not be immediately obvious amd take up to three generations to be detected.

To judge the welfare of GA rodents, those using them are advised to look for signs such as deformities, fur loss, reluctance to move, depression, seizures and death. Clearly, such conditions have been observed and are expected to occur in some GA animals. In the UK, the breeding of such animals account for the largest number of animals used in research.

The process of genetically modified animal production is hugely inefficient - only 3-5% of the babies actually have the desired genetic defect, so huge numbers are killed and discarded. Read about our investigation into a genetic modification laboratory in the UK.

1. Dennis, M. B (2002) “Welfare Issues of Genetically Modified Animals” ILAR journal, vol. 43, no. 2, pp: 100 -109

Find out about other EWG reports on
Education and training
Non-technical project summaries
Project evaluation/retrospective assessment
Severity assessment

Support our work to end animal experiments

© National Anti-Vivisection Society

Cookie preferences