National Anti-vivisection Society

 

National Antivisection Society

Animal use questioned in major scientific journal

Posted: 6 June 2014. Updated: 6 June 2014

The British Medical Journal published an article in May 2014 which seriously questioned ongoing claims that research on animals provides benefits to human health. The authors searched for evidence and found relatively few reviews of animal research to support such claims. Those they did find highlighted a multitude of problems with this assertion, raising “serious doubts about the design, quality, and relevance” of the studies.

Animal research is poor quality and poorly reported
Systematic reviews of animal studies showed how many were not addressing issues which could impact on the accuracy of the research, therefore making the prediction of results in humans “tenuous at best". Bias in the reporting of animal research was revealed, meaning that the validity of research was overstated. Attempts to “improve” the reporting of animal research, with the introduction of guidelines, have so far resulted in little improvement.

Relating data to humans
As a result of the overoptimistic conclusions regarding efficacy, from animal data, drugs are passed to human trials, with the consequence that even “the most promising” treatments fail. A number of reviews in areas such as stroke medicine and inflammation showed that large numbers of drugs have failed to translate to the human clinical situation, based on basic and preclinical animal research.

Animal models are broken models
Despite claims and selected examples chosen by the animal research community to attempt to show that their work provides advances in medicine, the authors point out how, given the large amount of animal research being conducted, “some findings will extrapolate to humans just by chance". With more and more species differences being acknowledged, including between humans and other primate species, it is suggested that even “faultlessly” conducted animal research would fail to relate to humans. Transgenic animals are described as contributing more to “an idea of a therapeutic promise” than having actual consequences in the clinic.

Optimistically, the article concludes that “animal research is no longer as immune from challenge or criticism as it once was", but that achieving change could be difficult due to the interest, not infrequently financial, of those involved in animal research in continuing as they always have. They also state that non-publication of animal studies is unethical because it may result in further, unnecessary animal and human experimentation. The authors state that the “current situation is unethical” and conclude that, if the established problems surrounding animal research continue, “the publicīs continuing endorsement and funding of preclinical animal research seems misplaced".

Donate now to help us campaign for an end to animal experiments

Find out more facts about vivisection

© National Anti-Vivisection Society

Cookie preferences