National Anti-vivisection Society

 

National Antivisection Society

Concordat on openness just a public relations ploy

Posted: 14 May 2014

A “Concordat on Openness in Animal Research in the UK” has been published with the backing of 72 signatories, including universities, charities, pharmaceutical companies and research councils. The document is purportedly "to enhance their communication about their use of animals."

Despite the fact that the concordat claims that the public should come to their own conclusions about animal research by being "provided with clear and honest information on the benefits of the research to humans and animals, and any harms to the animals used in research" the concordat, penned by big-pharma lobbyists, is nothing more than a ploy to appear open about animal experiments, whilst withholding details of grisly, failed and duplicate tests.

We have heard this before, with the animal experimenters´ spin on openness being more about justifying what they do than actually unlocking the labs. This is public relations and not transparency. It cannot replace independent scrutiny and open assessment of experiments before they take place. For example, “Commitment 2” includes providing a spokesperson for the media and informing the media when they believe their animal research "has played a significant role in a scientific advancement and/or product development".

An Ipsos-Mori poll in 2012, `Views on the use of animals in scientific research´, which sought the views of over 1,000 people, found that now only 36% accept animal testing for `environmentally or animal-harmful chemicals´, a decrease of 8% in two years, while fewer than half (46%) accept animal testing for “chemicals that may harm people", down 4% in two years. Significantly, 37% are now fully against all animal experiments, an increase of 8% since 2006. These figures show that the secrecy surrounding animal experiments is of benefit to no one, including animal researchers.

The Government has launched a consultation on the review of Section 24 of the Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act, which allows details of animal experiments to remain hidden and exempt from the Freedom of Information Act (2). The NAVS will be calling for repeal of the secrecy clause and for reliance on the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOIA). The FOIA already works for government, courts, the police, local government, the NHS and other bodies.

The NAVS also wants access to the project licence applications before they are granted to ensure adherence to the Government´s 3`Rs policy of replacement, reduction and refinement in animal experiments. Most importantly, this access would provide us with the necessary information to recommend alternatives, identify duplications or other comparable research, thus enabling us to challenge such research, before it starts.

If signatories to the concordat are truly committed to openness and transparency, we would hope to have their unreserved support for the repeal of the secrecy clause, and agreement to more rigorous scrutiny of project applications in the search for non-animal methods.

© National Anti-Vivisection Society

Cookie preferences