National Anti-vivisection Society

 

National Antivisection Society

APC consultation on the 'cost/benefit' assessments

In 2001, the Animal Procedures Committee conducted a consultation on the issue at the heart of the legislation - the cost/benefit assessment.

When someone applies for a Project Licence to use animals, the Animals Scientific Procedures Inspectorate (ASPI) conducts a ‘cost/benefit assessment’; this weighs the cost to the animals (in pain and suffering) against the potential benefits of the results from the experiments or procedures (new or safer products, potential human benefits).

The Cost/Benefit Assessment is a requirement of the Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986. The ASPI describe it as an ongoing process during the course of an application, and say that they continue to reasses during the course of a project.

There has been much debate about the considerations which go into a cost/benefit assessment, and when and how this is conducted. The ASPI asserts that the Cost/Benefit Assessment is not a one-off event, conducted at the application stage only.

Click here for a NAVS critique of the ‘cost/benefit assessment’ using examples of experiments allowed in the UK. This is from evidence the NAVS supplied to the Animal Procedures Committee consultation on the ‘cost/benefit assessment’ in 2001.


File downloads:
Cost/ Benefit Assessment
File name: Benefit_Assess.pdf
File size: 105.6KB
[Download]

Please note: the larger .pdf files may take some time to download, depending on connection speeds. Some browsers may not indicate that downloads are taking place.

© National Anti-Vivisection Society

Cookie preferences